Home / Weather / Financial have an effect on of calories intake trade led to by way of world warming

Financial have an effect on of calories intake trade led to by way of world warming

Reposted from Dr. Judith Curry’s Local weather And so forth.

Posted on February eight, 2020 by way of curryja |

by way of Peter Lang and Ken Gregory

A brand new paper ‘Financial have an effect on of calories intake trade led to by way of world warming’ unearths world warming could also be advisable.

On this weblog submit we reproduce the Summary, Coverage Implications and Conclusions and portions of the Advent, Effects and Dialogue. We inspire you to learn all of the paper.

Summary: This paper checks the validity of the FUND fashion’s calories have an effect on purposes, and the speculation that world warming of two °C or extra above pre-industrial instances would negatively have an effect on the worldwide economic system. Empirical knowledge of calories expenditure and moderate temperatures of america states and census divisions are when compared with projections the usage of the calories have an effect on purposes with non-temperature drivers held consistent at their 2010 values. The empirical knowledge signifies that calories expenditure decreases as temperatures build up, suggesting that world warming, on its own, would possibly cut back US calories expenditure and thereby have a favorable have an effect on on US financial expansion. Those findings are then when compared with FUND calories have an effect on projections for the arena at three °C of world warming from 2000. The comparisons recommend that warming, on its own, would possibly cut back world calories intake. If those findings are right kind, and if FUND projections for the non-energy have an effect on sectors are legitimate, three °C of world warming from 2000 would build up world financial expansion. On this case, the speculation is fake and insurance policies to cut back world warming are negative to the worldwide economic system. We advise the FUND calories have an effect on purposes be changed and recalibrated in opposition to best possible to be had empirical knowledge. Our research and conclusions warrant additional investigation.

Advent

There’s a clinical speculation and political acceptance that world warming of two °C or extra above pre-industrial instances would have a unfavorable have an effect on on world financial expansion. This speculation is supported by way of financial fashions that depend on have an effect on purposes and plenty of assumptions. On the other hand, the knowledge had to calibrate the have an effect on purposes is sparse, and the uncertainties within the modelling effects are massive. The unfavorable general have an effect on projected by way of a minimum of some of the major fashions, Local weather Framework for Uncertainty, Negotiation and Distribution (FUND), is most commonly because of one have an effect on sector – calories intake. On the other hand, the projected unfavorable have an effect on appears to be at odds with empirical knowledge. If this paper’s findings from the empirical calories intake knowledge are right kind, and if the have an effect on purposes for the non-energy sectors are right kind, then the full financial have an effect on of world warming could be advisable. If true, the consequences for local weather coverage are really extensive.

Built-in Review Fashions (IAM) roughly reproduce the projections from the International Local weather Fashions (GCM) and practice have an effect on purposes to estimate the commercial affects of world warming. The have an effect on purposes are derived from and calibrated to what the builders assess are probably the most appropriate research of the affects. The have an effect on purposes require many assumptions, together with projections of inhabitants, gross home product (GDP), consistent with capita source of revenue, elasticities and era growth in calories provision.

Quite a lot of research conclude that the have an effect on purposes (also known as harm purposes) used within the IAMs are derived from insufficient empirical knowledge. As an example, Pindyck says “on the subject of the wear serve as, on the other hand, we all know virtually not anything, so builders of IAMs can do little greater than make up practical paperwork and corresponding parameter values. And that’s just about what they have got performed.” In line with Kolstad et al., the IAM harm purposes “are generated from a outstanding paucity of knowledge and are thus of low reliability”. The Nationwide Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Drugs (NAS) says FUND wishes additional justification for the wear purposes, the difference assumptions for the other sectors, the regional distribution of damages, and the parametric uncertainties general. Tol says the have an effect on of local weather trade has now not gained enough consideration; he says “there may be both little or no forged proof, no conclusive proof, or no quantification of welfare affects”.

NAS  critiques the wear purposes of the 3 major IAMs, discusses selection approaches, critiques fresh literature on harm estimation, and gives suggestions for a brand new harm module. It says that a lot of the literature on which the wear purposes are based totally is dated and, in lots of instances, does now not mirror fresh advances within the clinical literature. For instance, the FUND calories have an effect on parameters are calibrated to breed the result of the 1996 papers by way of Downing et al.  and the source of revenue elasticity result of the 1995 paper by way of Hodgson and Miller.

FUND is among the 3 maximum cited IAMs; Bonen et al., Nationwide Analysis Council and NAS examine them. FUND is probably the most complicated. FUND disaggregates by way of 16 international areas and 8 major have an effect on sectors (agriculture, forestry, water assets, sea degree upward thrust, ecosystems, well being, excessive climate, and effort intake). This allows analysts to behavior sensitivity analyses and to one at a time check particular person have an effect on purposes.

Tol  used the nationwide model of FUND3.6 to backcast the commercial have an effect on of world warming for those sectors for the 20th century and projected the affects for the 21st century. Tol fitted the backcast effects to observations of 20th century sectoral affects. Tol  is the most important find out about as it estimates the affects for probably the most vital have an effect on sectors, globally and by way of area. It additionally estimates the whole have an effect on on all sectors.

The ground panel of Determine 1 means that an build up of as much as round four °C International Imply Floor Temperature (GMST) above pre-industrial instances could be advisable for the whole of all sectors if the projected calories affects for 2000–2100 are excluded. Power intake is projected to have a considerable unfavorable have an effect on all through the 21st century; actually, its unfavorable have an effect on exceeds the whole have an effect on of all different sectors, which is certain, from about 2080.

The putting trade in pattern of the calories have an effect on on the flip of the century impressed this find out about. The craze used to be certain as GMST larger by way of Zero.61 °C all through the 20th century however FUND tasks it’s going to be considerably unfavorable for the 21st century as GMST is projected to extend additional. This is, while the observations for 1900–2000 display the affects had been certain, FUND tasks endured world warming would have unfavorable affects for the worldwide economic system.

Opposite to the FUND calories projection for the length 2000–2100, america Power Data Management (EIA) empirical knowledge seem to suggest that world warming would cut back US calories expenditure and, due to this fact, give a contribution certain financial affects for the United States. The paper infers that the affects of world warming on america economic system could also be indicative of the affects at the world economic system.

If the commercial have an effect on of calories is close to 0 or certain, and if the whole of the sectoral projections in Determine 1, rather than for calories intake, is roughly right kind, world warming could be advisable as much as round three °C relative to 2000, and four °C relative to pre-industrial instances. The importance of those findings for local weather coverage is really extensive. As an example, insurance policies that purpose to cut back world warming would now not be economically justifiable. Due to this fact, the commercial have an effect on of calories intake projected in Tol, and by way of FUND3.nine, warrants investigation if FUND is for use for coverage.

This paper checks the validity of the FUND calories have an effect on purposes in opposition to US empirical knowledge. It examines EIA knowledge for the United States to research whether or not the have an effect on of world warming on US calories intake would cut back or build up US financial expansion and compares the effects with the calories projections. Subsequent it investigates the projections for FUND’s 16 international areas. Finally, it discusses some coverage implications.

Effects

Determine nine compares the projected US calories expenditure affects in opposition to the affects calculated from the EIA empirical knowledge.

Figure 9: Economic impact of US energy expenditure as functions of GMST change, relative to 2000. Pink solid line is the Julia FUND3.9 projection. Pink dashed line is the projection with non-temperature drivers constant at 2010 values. The orange dashed line is from the EIA data.

Determine nine: Financial have an effect on of US calories expenditure as purposes of GMST trade, relative to 2000. Crimson forged line is the Julia FUND3.nine projection. Crimson dashed line is the projection with non-temperature drivers consistent at 2010 values. The orange dashed line is from the EIA knowledge.

Determine nine presentations the projected affects are considerably unfavorable while the EIA knowledge presentations they’re certain.

Dialogue

Determine 15 plots the worldwide financial affects by way of sector as a serve as of GMST trade from 2000 to 2100 projected by way of FUND3.nine with non-temperature drivers integrated. The entire of all have an effect on sectors, and the whole except calories, also are proven.

Figure 15: FUND3.9 projected global sectoral economic impact of climate change as a function of GMST change from 2000. Total* is of all impact sectors except energy.

Determine 15: FUND3.nine projected world sectoral financial have an effect on of local weather trade as a serve as of GMST trade from 2000. General* is of all have an effect on sectors with the exception of calories.

With calories affects excluded, FUND tasks the worldwide affects to be +Zero.2% of GDP at three °C GMST build up from yr 2000. With the calories have an effect on purposes misspecifications corrected, and all different affects are as projected, the projected overall financial have an effect on could also be extra certain.

The belief that three °C of world warming could also be advisable for the worldwide economic system is dependent, partly, at the overall of the non-energy have an effect on projections being right kind, or extra certain. Whether or not that is the case must be examined.

Coverage Implications

The commercial have an effect on of local weather insurance policies may be really extensive. It’s the sum of the commercial have an effect on of the insurance policies and the price of enforcing and keeping up the insurance policies. If world warming is advisable, as this find out about signifies could also be the case, then the whole financial have an effect on is the sum of the forgone advantages of the have shyed away from world warming plus the price of insurance policies to mitigate warming.

Our research means that the full have an effect on of world warming could also be certain – this is, it might build up world financial expansion. If that is right kind, then the certain affects can also be maximised and the unfavorable affects minimised by way of expanding wealth, however now not by way of lowering world warming. Tol  concludes that the unfavorable affects of world warming can also be decreased by way of lowering world warming and/or lowering poverty. On the other hand, if world warming is advisable, then polices geared toward lowering world warming are lowering world financial expansion.

In line with Lomborg  any discounts in temperature on account of the Paris Settlement guarantees could be minimum however at prime price. For instance, Lomborg says that each one Paris guarantees 2016–2030 will cut back world temperatures by way of simply Zero.05 °C in 2100, and by way of Zero.17 °C in the event that they proceed to 2100. He estimates the perhaps price could be $1,848 billion consistent with yr in 2030. That is about 2% of projected international GDP in 2030, and this estimate does now not come with all prices of the local weather trade business.

Different research additionally point out that the price of insurance policies to cut back world warming is prime. For instance, Local weather Exchange Trade Magazine  estimates put the local weather trade business in 2013 at $1,405 billion, about 1.nine% of worldwide GDP. Additional, Insurance coverage Magazine says that the ‘local weather trade business’ grew at 17–24% yearly 2005–2008, four–6% following the recession, and 15% in 2011. Those expansion charges are a lot upper than the expansion charge of the arena economic system implying that, in the event that they proceed, which is most probably with world protocols, accords and agreements similar to Kyoto, Copenhagen and Paris, the price of local weather insurance policies will proceed to escalate.

Conclusions

This find out about checks the validity of the FUND calories have an effect on purposes by way of evaluating the projections in opposition to empirical house heating and house cooling calories knowledge and temperature knowledge for the United States. Non-temperature drivers are held consistent at their 2010 values for comparability with the empirical knowledge. The have an effect on purposes are examined at Zero° to three °C of world warming from 2000.

The research unearths that, opposite to the FUND projections, world warming of three °C relative to 2000 would cut back US calories expenditure and, due to this fact, would have a favorable have an effect on on US financial expansion. FUND tasks the commercial have an effect on to be -Zero.80% of GDP, while our research of the EIA knowledge signifies the have an effect on could be +Zero.07% of GDP. We infer that the have an effect on of world warming on calories intake could also be certain for the areas that produced 82% of the arena’s GDP in 2010 and, by way of inference, could also be certain for the worldwide economic system.

The importance of those findings for local weather coverage is really extensive. If the FUND sectoral financial have an effect on projections, rather than calories, are right kind, and the projected financial have an effect on of calories must in fact be close to 0 or certain relatively than unfavorable, then world warming of as much as round three °C relative to 2000, and four °C relative to pre-industrial instances, could be economically advisable, now not negative.

On this case, the speculation that world warming could be destructive to the worldwide economic system this century could also be false, and insurance policies to cut back world warming might not be justified. No longer adopting insurance policies to cut back world warming would yield the commercial advantages of warming and steer clear of the commercial prices of the ones insurance policies.

The discrepancy between the affects projected by way of FUND and the ones discovered from the EIA knowledge could also be because of a considerable share of the affects (37% for america and 67% for the arena) being because of non-temperature drivers, now not temperature trade, and to a couple unsuitable calories have an effect on serve as parameter values.

We advise that the FUND calories have an effect on purposes be changed and recalibrated in opposition to best possible to be had empirical knowledge. Additional, we advise that the validity of the non-energy have an effect on purposes be examined.

Reposted from Dr. Judith Curry’s Local weather And so forth.

Posted on February eight, 2020 by way of curryja |

by way of Peter Lang and Ken Gregory

A brand new paper ‘Financial have an effect on of calories intake trade led to by way of world warming’ unearths world warming could also be advisable.

On this weblog submit we reproduce the Summary, Coverage Implications and Conclusions and portions of the Advent, Effects and Dialogue. We inspire you to learn all of the paper.

Summary: This paper checks the validity of the FUND fashion’s calories have an effect on purposes, and the speculation that world warming of two °C or extra above pre-industrial instances would negatively have an effect on the worldwide economic system. Empirical knowledge of calories expenditure and moderate temperatures of america states and census divisions are when compared with projections the usage of the calories have an effect on purposes with non-temperature drivers held consistent at their 2010 values. The empirical knowledge signifies that calories expenditure decreases as temperatures build up, suggesting that world warming, on its own, would possibly cut back US calories expenditure and thereby have a favorable have an effect on on US financial expansion. Those findings are then when compared with FUND calories have an effect on projections for the arena at three °C of world warming from 2000. The comparisons recommend that warming, on its own, would possibly cut back world calories intake. If those findings are right kind, and if FUND projections for the non-energy have an effect on sectors are legitimate, three °C of world warming from 2000 would build up world financial expansion. On this case, the speculation is fake and insurance policies to cut back world warming are negative to the worldwide economic system. We advise the FUND calories have an effect on purposes be changed and recalibrated in opposition to best possible to be had empirical knowledge. Our research and conclusions warrant additional investigation.

Advent

There’s a clinical speculation and political acceptance that world warming of two °C or extra above pre-industrial instances would have a unfavorable have an effect on on world financial expansion. This speculation is supported by way of financial fashions that depend on have an effect on purposes and plenty of assumptions. On the other hand, the knowledge had to calibrate the have an effect on purposes is sparse, and the uncertainties within the modelling effects are massive. The unfavorable general have an effect on projected by way of a minimum of some of the major fashions, Local weather Framework for Uncertainty, Negotiation and Distribution (FUND), is most commonly because of one have an effect on sector – calories intake. On the other hand, the projected unfavorable have an effect on appears to be at odds with empirical knowledge. If this paper’s findings from the empirical calories intake knowledge are right kind, and if the have an effect on purposes for the non-energy sectors are right kind, then the full financial have an effect on of world warming could be advisable. If true, the consequences for local weather coverage are really extensive.

Built-in Review Fashions (IAM) roughly reproduce the projections from the International Local weather Fashions (GCM) and practice have an effect on purposes to estimate the commercial affects of world warming. The have an effect on purposes are derived from and calibrated to what the builders assess are probably the most appropriate research of the affects. The have an effect on purposes require many assumptions, together with projections of inhabitants, gross home product (GDP), consistent with capita source of revenue, elasticities and era growth in calories provision.

Quite a lot of research conclude that the have an effect on purposes (also known as harm purposes) used within the IAMs are derived from insufficient empirical knowledge. As an example, Pindyck says “on the subject of the wear serve as, on the other hand, we all know virtually not anything, so builders of IAMs can do little greater than make up practical paperwork and corresponding parameter values. And that’s just about what they have got performed.” In line with Kolstad et al., the IAM harm purposes “are generated from a outstanding paucity of knowledge and are thus of low reliability”. The Nationwide Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Drugs (NAS) says FUND wishes additional justification for the wear purposes, the difference assumptions for the other sectors, the regional distribution of damages, and the parametric uncertainties general. Tol says the have an effect on of local weather trade has now not gained enough consideration; he says “there may be both little or no forged proof, no conclusive proof, or no quantification of welfare affects”.

NAS  critiques the wear purposes of the 3 major IAMs, discusses selection approaches, critiques fresh literature on harm estimation, and gives suggestions for a brand new harm module. It says that a lot of the literature on which the wear purposes are based totally is dated and, in lots of instances, does now not mirror fresh advances within the clinical literature. For instance, the FUND calories have an effect on parameters are calibrated to breed the result of the 1996 papers by way of Downing et al.  and the source of revenue elasticity result of the 1995 paper by way of Hodgson and Miller.

FUND is among the 3 maximum cited IAMs; Bonen et al., Nationwide Analysis Council and NAS examine them. FUND is probably the most complicated. FUND disaggregates by way of 16 international areas and 8 major have an effect on sectors (agriculture, forestry, water assets, sea degree upward thrust, ecosystems, well being, excessive climate, and effort intake). This allows analysts to behavior sensitivity analyses and to one at a time check particular person have an effect on purposes.

Tol  used the nationwide model of FUND3.6 to backcast the commercial have an effect on of world warming for those sectors for the 20th century and projected the affects for the 21st century. Tol fitted the backcast effects to observations of 20th century sectoral affects. Tol  is the most important find out about as it estimates the affects for probably the most vital have an effect on sectors, globally and by way of area. It additionally estimates the whole have an effect on on all sectors.

The ground panel of Determine 1 means that an build up of as much as round four °C International Imply Floor Temperature (GMST) above pre-industrial instances could be advisable for the whole of all sectors if the projected calories affects for 2000–2100 are excluded. Power intake is projected to have a considerable unfavorable have an effect on all through the 21st century; actually, its unfavorable have an effect on exceeds the whole have an effect on of all different sectors, which is certain, from about 2080.

The putting trade in pattern of the calories have an effect on on the flip of the century impressed this find out about. The craze used to be certain as GMST larger by way of Zero.61 °C all through the 20th century however FUND tasks it’s going to be considerably unfavorable for the 21st century as GMST is projected to extend additional. This is, while the observations for 1900–2000 display the affects had been certain, FUND tasks endured world warming would have unfavorable affects for the worldwide economic system.

Opposite to the FUND calories projection for the length 2000–2100, america Power Data Management (EIA) empirical knowledge seem to suggest that world warming would cut back US calories expenditure and, due to this fact, give a contribution certain financial affects for the United States. The paper infers that the affects of world warming on america economic system could also be indicative of the affects at the world economic system.

If the commercial have an effect on of calories is close to 0 or certain, and if the whole of the sectoral projections in Determine 1, rather than for calories intake, is roughly right kind, world warming could be advisable as much as round three °C relative to 2000, and four °C relative to pre-industrial instances. The importance of those findings for local weather coverage is really extensive. As an example, insurance policies that purpose to cut back world warming would now not be economically justifiable. Due to this fact, the commercial have an effect on of calories intake projected in Tol, and by way of FUND3.nine, warrants investigation if FUND is for use for coverage.

This paper checks the validity of the FUND calories have an effect on purposes in opposition to US empirical knowledge. It examines EIA knowledge for the United States to research whether or not the have an effect on of world warming on US calories intake would cut back or build up US financial expansion and compares the effects with the calories projections. Subsequent it investigates the projections for FUND’s 16 international areas. Finally, it discusses some coverage implications.

Effects

Determine nine compares the projected US calories expenditure affects in opposition to the affects calculated from the EIA empirical knowledge.

Figure 9: Economic impact of US energy expenditure as functions of GMST change, relative to 2000. Pink solid line is the Julia FUND3.9 projection. Pink dashed line is the projection with non-temperature drivers constant at 2010 values. The orange dashed line is from the EIA data.

Determine nine: Financial have an effect on of US calories expenditure as purposes of GMST trade, relative to 2000. Crimson forged line is the Julia FUND3.nine projection. Crimson dashed line is the projection with non-temperature drivers consistent at 2010 values. The orange dashed line is from the EIA knowledge.

Determine nine presentations the projected affects are considerably unfavorable while the EIA knowledge presentations they’re certain.

Dialogue

Determine 15 plots the worldwide financial affects by way of sector as a serve as of GMST trade from 2000 to 2100 projected by way of FUND3.nine with non-temperature drivers integrated. The entire of all have an effect on sectors, and the whole except calories, also are proven.

Figure 15: FUND3.9 projected global sectoral economic impact of climate change as a function of GMST change from 2000. Total* is of all impact sectors except energy.

Determine 15: FUND3.nine projected world sectoral financial have an effect on of local weather trade as a serve as of GMST trade from 2000. General* is of all have an effect on sectors with the exception of calories.

With calories affects excluded, FUND tasks the worldwide affects to be +Zero.2% of GDP at three °C GMST build up from yr 2000. With the calories have an effect on purposes misspecifications corrected, and all different affects are as projected, the projected overall financial have an effect on could also be extra certain.

The belief that three °C of world warming could also be advisable for the worldwide economic system is dependent, partly, at the overall of the non-energy have an effect on projections being right kind, or extra certain. Whether or not that is the case must be examined.

Coverage Implications

The commercial have an effect on of local weather insurance policies may be really extensive. It’s the sum of the commercial have an effect on of the insurance policies and the price of enforcing and keeping up the insurance policies. If world warming is advisable, as this find out about signifies could also be the case, then the whole financial have an effect on is the sum of the forgone advantages of the have shyed away from world warming plus the price of insurance policies to mitigate warming.

Our research means that the full have an effect on of world warming could also be certain – this is, it might build up world financial expansion. If that is right kind, then the certain affects can also be maximised and the unfavorable affects minimised by way of expanding wealth, however now not by way of lowering world warming. Tol  concludes that the unfavorable affects of world warming can also be decreased by way of lowering world warming and/or lowering poverty. On the other hand, if world warming is advisable, then polices geared toward lowering world warming are lowering world financial expansion.

In line with Lomborg  any discounts in temperature on account of the Paris Settlement guarantees could be minimum however at prime price. For instance, Lomborg says that each one Paris guarantees 2016–2030 will cut back world temperatures by way of simply Zero.05 °C in 2100, and by way of Zero.17 °C in the event that they proceed to 2100. He estimates the perhaps price could be $1,848 billion consistent with yr in 2030. That is about 2% of projected international GDP in 2030, and this estimate does now not come with all prices of the local weather trade business.

Different research additionally point out that the price of insurance policies to cut back world warming is prime. For instance, Local weather Exchange Trade Magazine  estimates put the local weather trade business in 2013 at $1,405 billion, about 1.nine% of worldwide GDP. Additional, Insurance coverage Magazine says that the ‘local weather trade business’ grew at 17–24% yearly 2005–2008, four–6% following the recession, and 15% in 2011. Those expansion charges are a lot upper than the expansion charge of the arena economic system implying that, in the event that they proceed, which is most probably with world protocols, accords and agreements similar to Kyoto, Copenhagen and Paris, the price of local weather insurance policies will proceed to escalate.

Conclusions

This find out about checks the validity of the FUND calories have an effect on purposes by way of evaluating the projections in opposition to empirical house heating and house cooling calories knowledge and temperature knowledge for the United States. Non-temperature drivers are held consistent at their 2010 values for comparability with the empirical knowledge. The have an effect on purposes are examined at Zero° to three °C of world warming from 2000.

The research unearths that, opposite to the FUND projections, world warming of three °C relative to 2000 would cut back US calories expenditure and, due to this fact, would have a favorable have an effect on on US financial expansion. FUND tasks the commercial have an effect on to be -Zero.80% of GDP, while our research of the EIA knowledge signifies the have an effect on could be +Zero.07% of GDP. We infer that the have an effect on of world warming on calories intake could also be certain for the areas that produced 82% of the arena’s GDP in 2010 and, by way of inference, could also be certain for the worldwide economic system.

The importance of those findings for local weather coverage is really extensive. If the FUND sectoral financial have an effect on projections, rather than calories, are right kind, and the projected financial have an effect on of calories must in fact be close to 0 or certain relatively than unfavorable, then world warming of as much as round three °C relative to 2000, and four °C relative to pre-industrial instances, could be economically advisable, now not negative.

On this case, the speculation that world warming could be destructive to the worldwide economic system this century could also be false, and insurance policies to cut back world warming might not be justified. No longer adopting insurance policies to cut back world warming would yield the commercial advantages of warming and steer clear of the commercial prices of the ones insurance policies.

The discrepancy between the affects projected by way of FUND and the ones discovered from the EIA knowledge could also be because of a considerable share of the affects (37% for america and 67% for the arena) being because of non-temperature drivers, now not temperature trade, and to a couple unsuitable calories have an effect on serve as parameter values.

We advise that the FUND calories have an effect on purposes be changed and recalibrated in opposition to best possible to be had empirical knowledge. Additional, we advise that the validity of the non-energy have an effect on purposes be examined.

About admin

Check Also

Pacific Islands must stop relying on foreign aid to adapt to climate change, because the money won’t last

Pacific Islands should forestall depending on international support to evolve to weather alternate, since the cash gained’t ultimate

Patrick Nunn, Creator supplied Patrick D. Nunn, College of the Sunshine Coast and Roselyn Kumar, …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *